Saturday, April 2, 2011

Cosi mid-range essay

The following student example is a mid-range response from the 2010 Assessment Report.


‘Cosi is more than an entertaining comedy. It reveals the sadness of the lives of the characters.’

Discuss.

Throught the play Cosi the audience witnesses the lives of mentally ill people unfold before them. Louis Nowra has used black comedy within Cosi to allow the audience to abandon their pre-conceptions of ‘mad’ people and to see the characters not for their illness but for their personality. Because of this the audience is able to relate to each character and their situation and realise the underlying sadness of the patients lives. We are confronted by their pasts as we come to realise the causes for their illnesses; like with Roy as we learn of his childhood, abandoned by his mother and growing up in orphanages. Cosi also reveals the sadness within the lives of those who society considers ‘sain’ as the audience is treated to the life of the protagonist Lewis
Riley and the struggles and dependence he faces.

The truth of Roy’s life is one of the most shocking revelations to the audience as he often puts on a outgoing happy façade. With his vibrently outgoing personality Roy becomes one of the central figures of the play. He influences Lewis into directing the Italian opera ‘Cosi Fan Tutte’ and captivates Lewis with tales of music and performance from his childhood. This illusion that Roy casts over Lewis, and the audience alike, is seen for what it truely is as we learn that the stories were all lies and what Roy never new his mother. ‘I had a dream, Jerry.’ This quote from Roy reveals Roy’s sadness as audience has an epiphany that Roy’s tales of music and performance, along with his desire to performer ‘Cosi Fan Tutte’, are his way of trying to escape the sadness of his life spent unloved within orphanages and the asylum.

We witness similar sadness in the life of one of the other patients, Ruth. The audience first sees Ruth as being obsessive compulsive with a need for control over her life. Ruth’s behaviour is very methodical and she finds trouble gasping the concept of illusion as it isn’t something that she is able to control. During the scene in Cosi where the power goes out Ruth tells the story of her abusive ex-love who would lock her in the cupboard for extended periods of time. This story reveals Ruth’s sadness and the cause for her disorder as the aroma of not being in control of her life and being helpless against her ex-lover has scared her into having an obsession for control in her life. From this point within the play the audience feels sympathy for Ruth as they understand her sadness.

Along with the patients of the asylum we also come to realize the sadness with the life of the protagonist Lewis Riley. We first encounter Lewis as a university drop-out who takes the directing job at the asylum. Lewis ‘lacks direction…in life and only takes the job’ for the money. During the scene where Lewis’ friend Nick comes to help direct is where the audience truely comes to realise the sadness with Lewis’ life as the audience realises that Lewis’ beliefs and values are not genuine and dirive from his dependence on his girlfriend Lucy and Nick. We see his political views, views on love and fidelity and whats important in life are
just mimicing Nick and Lucy’s, which shows the sadness of Lewis’ lack of self and dependence on others. Lewis does redeem himself by the end of the play by finding happiness that he lacked before and finding his identity.

Cosi is more than a comedy. It draws the audience in as they become immersed in the lives of the cast. The revelation of the sadness felt by the characters helps to deepen our connection as we relate to them and see them as imperfect humans life ourselves.

Assessor comments

• A competent essay which provides an accurate response to the topic, dealing in a sometimes superficial way with its main concerns.

• The piece is organised around a discussion of the sadness felt by some of the characters: an approach which is appropriate, but which also results in a somewhat narrow selection of evidence from the play.

• The student shows adequate knowledge of the text through some pertinent description of key events and some close referencing via quotes.

• The student’s expression is generally fluent, although it is marked by slips in spelling and punctuation.

Cosi Revision Quiz

SECTION ONE: WHO SAID THAT?

1. Love is what you feel when you don’t have enough emotion left to hate.

2.The most important thing is to feel you are in control, but still at the same time listening. Are you listening, do you feel you are in control?

3. Barricades and bombs? Why not? Australians, especially young Australians of my age, are getting fed up with our society. We want changes and we want them now!

4. They are normal people who have done extraordinary things, thought extraordinary thoughts.

5. Yes, the more real it is, the more real it is.

6. This Cosi condones the cccorruption of innocence. Women are told to be tramps. Free love. Women are not to be trusted.

7. Couldn’t direct traffic down a one way street.

8. Eat! Get some flesh on your bones.

9. You’re not deaf are you? The last thing we want is a deaf director. So what district? Suburb? Locale?

10. Women are God’s punishment for men playing with themselves.

11. I had to go and see one of the shrinks. They don’t know how to deal with drug users. He called it a ‘crutch’, I said it was a ‘rocket to the stars’. Needless to say, we didn’t get on.

12. I have sex with him and sleep with you.

13. I dropped a ciggie down the toilet.

14. Marvellous. Just marvellous, Lewis….And the cast! Didn’t think it was possible. Came right out of their shells. They blossomed. Blossomed!

15. Its about important things – like love and fidelity.

16. Without this, the world wouldn’t be the same. It would break, like a voice in despair shattering glass.



SECTION TWO: KNOW YOUR FACTS

1. Which character was tied up and locked in a cupboard by her ex-boyfriend?

2. Where is the play set? Be specific, and explain the symbolic significance of the setting.

3. Which opera is performed by the cast, and who is it by?

4. Why is Doug institutionalized?

5. Describe Henry’s view of his parents and what they were like.

6. Describe Nick and his relationship to both Lucy and Lewis.

7. List as many different view of love as you can – think of the views of various characters.

8. Who changes the most in the play? Give reasons for your answer.

9. Give a brief summary of the plot of the opera.

10. Lewis tells us the fate of the characters in the play. List as many as you can remember.

Cosi Love Essay

“Love is not so important nowadays.”

‘Cosi is a play about the importance of love and fidelity regardless of time and place.’ Do you agree?


To get you started

Circle the key words – write definitions (dictionary) or synonyms (Thesaurus) for these words.

Make the prompt as simple as possible, what am I being asked to agree/disagree with?

Draw a continuum, put agree at one end, disagree at the other. Mark in each character on the continuum. Now mark in your view on the continuum.



Introduction- There are four things that should occur in your introduction, they are

• Mention the text/author or a character (You are actually familiar with the text)

• Reword the statement/question , use alternate words for a concept or use an aspect of a concept e.g. Love, you might use ‘trust’ as this is an aspect of love.

• Show your point of view clearly. (How much you agree/disagree.)

• Signpost aspects of the topic that you will discuss in the following paragraphs.

(These four things don’t have to happen in this order.)

Possible introduction:

Lewis’s uncertain assertion about the importance of love early in the play Cosi, does not completely convince himself, nor the audience. We see Lewis’s loyalty and commitment tested in the rapidly changing society of 1970s Australia, and this theme is played out with its misunderstandings, pain and humour in 18th century Naples. Lewis comes to understand the value of honesty and warmth in his growing attachment to his cast and realises his values aren’t shared by Lucy and Nick.


Following paragraphs. Look back at your notes, which quotes draw attention to the issues being referred to in the statement.? How might you include some of these quotes? Which characters will you discuss?

Your paragraphs must contain the following, you may tinker with the style, but these elements must occur in the paragraph.

Topic sentence – a statement that indicates what the paragraph is about.

Expansion or Explanation of the topic sentence (more information)

Evidence- a quote or incident from the text that backs up what you said in the topic sentence.

Link- Link what you have said to the statement/question or link the sentence to what you are going to talk about in the next paragraph.

This will be referred to as the TEEL structure.

In this type of writing, a paragraph should never have less than four sentences. It may have more than four sentences, but it should never have less.



Possible topic sentences- (They don’t link at all. Use as many or few as necessary. Don’t use any if you wish.)

Fidelety, or loyalty to a person or cause, takes many forms in Cosi.

Love is fine for those who find it, but food in your belly and a roof over your head are of far more immediate importance.

Once Guglielmo and Ferrando take on the challenge of examining virtue, the seeds of mistrust are sown.

Henry ferociously guards his father’s memory, while calling into question the values of his ‘temptress’ wife.

Nick is single minded in his desire to ‘radicalise’ the middle classes of Australia.

Although events occur in different times and places, the human need to love and be loved is unchanging.

Love is the cream on the cake, but not a necessity for survival.

Women and men have been unfaithful to each other since time began and this is not likely to change.

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

Essay questions

Essay questions for you to practice over the revision period

HOW THE AUTHOR CONSTRUCTS MEANING QUESTIONS

1. ‘The play within the play enables the audience to gain a deeper insight into the plight of the characters.’ To what extent do you agree?
2. ‘Nowra uses comedy to challenge our perceptions about mental illness and what it means to be “normal”.’ Discuss

3. Cosi is a play within a play. How does Nowra use this theatrical device to explore his major themes?

4. How does Nowra use theatrical conventions to explore the ideas of reality and illusion?

CHARACTER QUESTIONS

1. “The patients are merely foils to the character of Lewis – it is his transformation that is the focus of the drama.” Discuss this point of view with reference to scenes and lines from the play.


2. How is the character of Lewis central to Cosi?

3. ‘While Lewis may be the play’s protagonist Roy is undoubtedly its star.’ Discuss.

4. ‘We admire Lewis for the moral stance he takes.’ To what extent do you agree?

5. “Working with these people has changed you.” (Lucy)

Lewis is not the same man as he was the beginning of the play. Discuss.

6. ‘Lewis’ involvement in the play transforms him to a remarkable extent.’ Discuss.

USING A CHARACTER TO ILLUSTRATE A THEME

1. ‘Cosi confirms Justin’s inadvertent insight that these are ‘normal people who have done extraordinary things, thought extraordinary thoughts’.’ Do you agree?


2. ‘The depiction of the politically committed characters in Cosi represents a distorted view of the student movement.’ Do you agree?

3. ‘The characters in Cosi suggest that we are all longing for purpose and intimacy in our lives.’ Discuss.

4. ‘The characters in Cosi are simply “normal people who have done extraordinary things.” To what extent do you agree?

5. Both the characters from the “normal world” and the characters from the asylum are driven by the human need for art. Discuss.

6. What is most extraordinary about the characters in the play is their everyday ordinariness. Discuss.

7. Cosi succeeds because we see the characters as people first and patients second. Discuss.

8. ‘Lewis benefits more from the production of Cosi Fan Tutte than the patients he has been hired to direct.’ Do you agree?

DEMONSTRATING AN UNDERSTANDING OF A KEY THEME/IDEA/VALUE

1. ‘Nowra challenges his audience with their own attitudes to madness and addiction.’ Discuss.


2. ‘Cosi demonstrates that most of our attitudes to mental illness are based in  ignorance.’ Do you agree?

3. ‘Nowra challenges his audience with their own stereotypes about madness and addiction.’ Discuss.

4. ‘Amidst the frivolity of Cosi’s comic episodes is a sombre examination of our treatment of mental illness.’ Discuss.

5. Cosi shows us that ‘fairytale endings’ do not reflect real life. How does Nowra’s play show us the complexity of people’s existence?


6. ‘Cosi shows that the desire for art flourishes in the most unlikely of environments.’ Discuss.

7. ‘Nowra examines how political commitment without human empathy is a hollow project.’ Discuss.

8. ‘Creative fulfilment and the richness of an imaginative life are the most effective forms of therapy.’ Do you agree?

9. Cosi shows us that the theatre has the power to transform lives. To what extent do you agree?

10. Cosi Fan Tutti is essentially a misogynistic opera and this is reflected in the depiction of the women in the play. To what extent do you agree?

11. ‘Cosi presents us with the consequences of ‘unresolved conflicts’. Discuss.

12. ‘This play condemns love as “an emotional indulgence for the privileged few.” Discuss.

13. Louis Nowra’s play Cosi questions the authenticity of love’ Discuss

14. ‘Nowra shows that it is the confinement inherent in institutional life that exacerbates the conditions of patients.’ Discuss.

15. Cosi shows us that there is as much madness in the outside world as there is within a mental institution. Discuss.

16. “Love is not so important nowadays.”

17. ‘Cosi is a play about the importance of love and fidelity regardless of time and place.’ Do you agree?
18. “I can live with illusion as long as I know it’s illusion, but this coffee is not real, is it?”
‘Cosi challenges us to question what is real and what is illusion.’ Discuss.

19. Cosi is a reminder of how vulnerable people are. To what extent do you agree?


20. Cosi demonstrates that only those who are prepared to take risks who achieve success. Discuss

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Zac

Name: Zac - mental patient, musician, house painter
Personal qualities: funny, placid on drugs, horny, excitable of drugs, Caught in his own world

Relationships: Zac doesn’t form any relationships due to him either being catatonic, on drugs or hyper active off drugs. This leads him to only have brief momentary conversations only really forming acquaintances and the other cast members. He pursues Ruth for a sexual relationship. Seems oblivious to the inappropriateness of this.

Conflict: Zac’s major conflict is with Ruth when he pulls up her skirt during he blackout and she pushes him over. But he also has conflicts with Roy about the play with the direction of the music, set painting and who wrote the opera.

Motivational goals: Zac is motivated by music and music alone. It is his motivation/direction to continue in the play. His musical aspirations are also shown when he attains minor success with a band.

Zac Key Quotes:
‘I’m prepared to play this pissy score for the whole opera, only if I do the overture my way, or else its exit the pianist.'

‘A lower dosage, it’s amazing how much more bright the world seems.’


‘Hey, let’s have an orgy.’


‘Women. You have to wrap it all up in fancy language and then they swoon for you when all it comes down to it the same thing.’


‘Women are god’s punishment for men playing with themselves.’

by Sarah & Jason

Other things to note about Zac:
Zac is also a source of humour - insisting on an overture by Wagner rather than Mozart - totally irrelevant in the scheme of things. Also his dramatic collapse on stage at the end after taking too many pills to calm his nerves.
Nowra uses this character to criticise the use of inappropriate dosages of  medication in treating mental illness. His whole existence is influenced by how much drugs he has in his system - from catatonic to manic. Note that once he is out of the institution he is able to function normally.

Ruth

DETAILS:
Aged between 30 & 40. Ruth has been in and out of institutions due to her Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD). She tends to be fixated on the minor details that Lewis seems to overlook. Because of her OCD she doesn’t cope with the idea of illusion and has difficulty comprehending anything other than literal interpretations.

PERSONAL QUALITIES:
A survivor
Resilient
Determined
Controlled
Obsessive
Hopeful
Needy
Dull
Fragile - needs reassurance

RELATIONSHIPS & CONFLICT:
Ruth has not had happy relationships in her life. During the blackout she reveals that her ex-boyfriend used to tie her up and keep her locked up in a wardrobe so as she would run away. She has since then come to the conclusion that he only wanted her for sex. They soon broke up after she slashed his tyres.

Also during the blackout (after revealing her past relationship) Zac feels Ruth up in an attempt to have sex with her. She warns him to stop but he continues with no hesitation after her warnings. She slaps him in the face after persisting, leading to a bloody nose for Zac.

Ruth has not got many friends or friendships which is evident that she more of a solitary figure.

MOTIVATION AND GOALS:
One goal of Ruth’s to finish the play to her best ability, she does not state it directly but it is evident as to how much she thinks about her every move. (even with the (OCD).

EMOTIONAL AND INTELLECTUAL GROWTH:

At the end of the play Lewis announces that Ruth left the institution to become a time and motion expert. This shows intellectual growth as it shows she is able to sustain a career and become an expert as well as make her own decisions.

Lewis mentioned nothing about Ruth getting married or having a boyfriend or kids. This may be that she has still not developed emotionally to have a stable relationship.

KEY QUOTES:

“So we’ll pretend” Act1Sc pg10

“…I’m not going to sing a song that is not word perfect.” Act1Sc2 pg13

“I can live with illusion as long as I know it’s illusion” Act1Sc3 pg26

“I can handle something being an illusion or real but not at the same time” Act1Sc3 pg26

“You’re doing a fine job of messing with my head!” Act1Sc3 pg29

“How many steps do you want me to take?... Large or small? Because, if its small, then it could be up to ten, maybe eleven.” Act1Sc3 pg30

“Learnt my lines. I’m word perfect. Go on, test me… Any place, any time. I know what I’m doing and everyone else. Test me.” Act1Sc4 pg38

“Yes, the more real it is, the more real it is” Act2Sc1 pg60

“Comedy is better when it’s real.” Act2Sc1 pg61

“I used to have a boyfriend who tied me up…so I wouldn’t run away. Four knots or maybe it was three.” Act2Sc1 pg66

“He just wanted me for sex. Men like sex more than women because they don’t have to clean up the mess” Act2Sc1 pg66

“I don’t care who you are – stop it!... Touch me again and I’ll make you regret it!” Act2Sc1 pg67

“I hate goodbyes, so when the others come out tell them im waiting outside counting the stars” Act2Sc5 pg85

by Emily, Megan Cassie & Cori

Other things to note about Ruth:
Humour - becomes a time and motion expert once she leaves the institution
Is used by Nowra to explore the theme of illusion and reality

Julie

NAME/DETAILS:
-Julie is in her early 20’s
-Has is a drug addiction
-She is the most ‘normal’ inmate
-Is in a lesbian relationship
-Newest to the ward
-Falls for Lewis
-Has a cynical view on love
-Understands and appreciates the opera
-Dies of a drug overdose

PERSONAL QUALITIES:
-Attractive -Unassuming -Subdued -Passive
-Appealing -Open minded -Surveys -Probing
-Honest -Loyal -Non-judgemental -Opinionative

-Vulnerable -Quiet -Straightforward -Considerate

RELATIONSHIPS
-Still has contact with her family even though they were people who put her in the institution saying “They think it’s sort of a holiday”
-Has a girlfriend
-Falls for Lewis during the play
-Is excluded from the other inmates

CONFLICTS
-Cherry thinks Julie likes Lewis so she becomes very jealous towards Julie. Cherry has a love at first sight relationship with Lewis and is very protective of him. As a result Cherry attempts to stab Julie with her flick knife when she hears fake rumours of them being together.

MOTIVATION/GOALS
-Wants to get out of the asylum
-Persists for the play to go ahead
-Moves to Sydney

EMOTIONAL& INTELLECTUAL GROWTH
-Stays with her girlfriend even though she falls for Lewis, because she feels she needs someone stable in her life


-Gets to leave the asylum to live in the normal world, because they think she has overcome her drug addiction. In the end, she dies of a drug overdose not so long after release somewhere in Sydney, which identifies even though she was sane and got put in a mental institution and was released she ended up no better than the other patients or possibly worse.

JULIE QUOTES

“I had to go and see one of the shrinks. They don’t know how to deal with drug users”
“Rocket to the stars – (referring to drugs)”
“A laugh is as good as a fuck, they say.”
“I would love to hit up right now."
“My parents had me committed; they think it’s sort of a holiday.”
“Doug hates them because he likes to be naturally high all the time. Zac likes them because everything passes like he’s in a dream or limbo.”
“Drugs make me feel sort of living.”
“Some people can’t imagine life without love; well I can’t imagine life without junk.”
“I’d just shot up. Beautiful stuff. Felt like mercury, no finger could hold me down.”
”Hairdresser. I’d do a good job on you now because I’m not on junk.”
“That’s what love is, being foolish.”
“I’ve always thought that love was being foolish and stupid. It’s about being on the edge and I like being on the edge. It’s not divine madness like some people think, there’s no such thing as divine madness, madness is just madness. Love is hallucinating without drugs.”
“That’s what I hate about the wards- they-re never really totally dark.”
“It’s just as easy for women to fall in love as it is for a man.”
“I think I fell for you.”
“I need something stable in my life. I need my girlfriend.”

by Jenna & Lauren